Wednesday, March 20, 2024
אֵלִי אֵלִי לָמָה עֲזַבְתָּנִי
My God, my God, why have You abandoned me?
A Talmudic tradition (B Megillah 15b.7) puts verses from Psalms 22 in the mouth of Queen Esther as she enters the inner throne room to begin the process of saving the Jews. In the past, that connection did not speak to me. However, this year everything is different and I also spent many hours studying the Psalm (source sheet here). Gradually, the connection became clear.
In verses 2-22 (as numbered in Jewish bibles), the psalmist describes nightmarish threats and danger. Then, in verse 23, there is a reversal of fortunes very similar to the reversal of the Jews' fate in the Book of Esther. And very similar to the prayer that many Jews have recited with increased intensity for the last 166 days: "Have compassion upon them, and bring them from distress to relief, from darkness to light, from subjugation to redemption, now, speedily."
Speedily and in our days.
I highly recommend this moving musical rendition of select verses (in Hebrew), by Ittai Binnun and AndraLaMoussia.
Monday, February 19, 2024
The Haftarah for Tetzaveh: Rebuilding
[Now] you, O mortal, describe the Temple to the House of Israel, and let them measure its design. But let them be ashamed of their iniquities. When they are ashamed of all they have done, make known to them the plan of the Temple and its layout, its exits and entrances—its entire plan, and all the laws and instructions pertaining to its entire plan. Write it down before their eyes, that they may faithfully follow its entire plan and all its laws. (Ezekiel 43:10-11)
Scroll down for Hebrew
By the rivers of Babylon, the prophet Ezekiel is commanded to convey a double message to the Israelites, of both hope and repentance. The hope is that they will eventually be able to rebuild the Temple, according to the precise description given by the prophet.[1] The repentance entails remorse for their actions, but the causal connection between the two is vague.
Rashi (Troyes, France, 11th century) understood that the description of the future temple was intended to be an ameliorating factor: “I show them that in My loving-kindness I have not rejected them for their iniquity.” In other words, the knowledge that God has not abandoned God’s people provides the protective context without which repentance is frightening.
For Rabbi David Kimchi (Provence, 12th century), the causal relationship is more direct; the people’s sins caused the destruction of the Temple. Confronting with the consequences of destruction ought to rattle them into understanding that actions have consequences and that they bear at least some degree of responsibility for their current situation. The rest of his words must be read very carefully, “Tell them that the future temple will never be destroyed because they will do not sin.” This is not a promise that the future temple will never be destroyed regardless of circumstances, but rather that it will stand forever because they will not continue to sin. As we well know, the Second Temple was indeed destroyed.
According to Don Isaac Abravanel (Portugal and Italy, 15th century), the subject of Ezekiel’s prophecy is not past sins that caused the First Temple to be destroyed, but rather his listeners’ current sins that prevent the return to Zion:
It is more correct to interpret that because the Israelites in Ezekiel’s day sinned by worshipping the sun and moon, God commanded the prophet to tell them everything he saw in his prophecy about rebuilding of the Temple, so that they would separate themselves, pay attention to the details of the Temple, measure its pattern, and thereby... realize their mistaken worship.
Perhaps they are all correct. Durable reconstruction depends on recognizing the mistakes that caused the destruction, and also those that currently prevent restoration, which can best be clarified and repaired in a non-confrontational environment.
The First Temple was destroyed. The Second Temple was destroyed. The State of Israel suffered a severe blow but is still standing. As we read in Ezekiel's prophecy, rehabilitation depends on soul-searching.
_______________
[1] The details are not identical to those given in the Book of Exodus, but that is not relevant here.
Saturday, February 3, 2024
How do we Bless? Parashat Yitro 5724
“Every act of reading from the Torah is a new giving of the Torah, a revival of the wondrous stand at the foot of the flaming mountain. The reading of the Torah is a ‘staging’ of the giving of the Torah and a renewal of the awesome, sublime experience, The revelational experience is reenacted whenever the Torah scroll is removed from the ark for reading in the synagogue,” wrote Rabbi Yosef Dov Soloveitchik (adapted from And from There You Shall Seek, Naomi Blum, trans.). Therefore, he would stand for the entire reading, all year round. That is a rare custom; most of us make do with standing during the readings of the Song of the Sea and the Ten Commandments, in order to evoke the feeling of “we were there.” Not only the standing, but the very reading from a Torah scroll written on parchment and the entire accompanying ritual were meant to create an elevated experience. If the purpose of the reading were limited to conveying information, we would read from a printed book, which would be more accurate, more convenient, and faster.
The full ritual surrounding the reading of the Torah developed slowly over the centuries,[1] but some important components are based on another formative event in the history of our nation, the precedent-setting reading of the Torah after the first return to Zion, as narrated in the Book of Nehemiah (8:5-6): “Ezra opened the scroll in the sight of all the people, for he was above all the people; as he opened it, all the people stood up. Ezra blessed the ETERNAL, the great God, and all the people answered, ‘Amen, Amen.’”
This is the first mention of a blessing on reading Torah. The text of Ezra’s blessing has not been preserved. In the Babylonian Talmud, the sages discuss the obligation to recite a blessing before and after a public reading of the Torah but prescribe a text only for the blessings on individual Torah study. Faced with the three persuasive proposals, the Sages chose a clearly Talmudic compromise: say them all.
The first blessing in this series (on page 25 in Siddur veAni Tefillati) begins as a regular mitzvah blessing “which we sanctified with his commandments and commandments” but the ending varies between manuscripts of the Talmud, with a corresponding difference in prayer customs, even today. In Ashkenazi versions, the ending is “to engage לעסוקin the words of the Torah.” Note the verb “to engage,” to be actively involved. When we hear, read or study Torah, the mitzvah is to bring with us all our knowledge, wisdom, life experience and concern.
The well-known blessing “Who chose us from among all the nations and gave us Torah…. giver of the Torah” originates in the same paragraph. It was adopted for public reading as early as the ninth century, in Babylon, and is found in Seder Rav Amram, the earliest Siddur that survived to our day.
Tractate Soferim, compiled in the Land of Israel, sometime after the Talmud, states, “An individual who rises early to read [=study] says the blessing, “Who gave us Torah from heaven and eternal life from on high….” (13:8).
Some time later, also in the Land of Israel, midrash Deuteronomy Rabbah was compiled, combining law and narrative. After stating, “A Jew who ascends to read Torah [in our terminology, “is given an aliyah”] is not allowed to read prior to blessing,” the Midrash returns us to Mount Sinai. If any Jew must bless when going up to the Torah, surely Moses blessed when he went up to receive it. –– May Moshe ben Amram Halevi and Yocheved stand for the first aliyah! –– Rabbi Elazar asks, “What blessing did Moses say?” and replies, “Who chose this Torah, and sanctified and desires those who fulfill [literally, “do”] it.” The Midrash goes on to emphasize, “And he did not say ‘those who pour over it,’ and he did not say ‘those who think about it,’ but rather ‘those who do it,’ those who fulfill words of the Torah” (11:6).
The blessings from Tractate Soferim and Deuteronomy Rabbah are likely familiar to many of you. Rabbi Tzvi Graetz presented them in his class on liturgy according to the ancient rite of the Land of Israel, based on the work of the late Rabbi Simcha Roth and his father, Rabbi Michael Graetz; some members have adopted them as their practice when having an aliyah. Over the past two weeks, I corresponded and conversed with some of them, in order to understand what motivates them. They all responded similarly: discontent (to put it mildly) with the idea that God has chosen Israel from all nations. For example:
One of my problems with the God who chooses is that I don’t think that God can also be the “God of truth and justice,” because when there is preference, there is no justice. When I had an aliyah I said, “With all nations,” but that was an evasion, not a statement. When I learned this blessing, it spoke to me and I was happy to discover that there are other ways to give thanks for the Torah without appropriating it and without aggrandizing ourselves.
I share this position but also want to nuance it. With all the problematics of being people that considers itself as chosen and exalted, we are nonetheless blessing – in one form or another – a Torah in which God makes a special covenant with Abraham and his descendants. For me, the crucial point is not the choice but the doing, as the blessing states, “Who sanctified and desires those who fulfill it.” The important thing is not only to receive Torah but to enact the righteousness, justice and loving kindness that it commands.
Similarly, the blessing formulated by Rabbi Mordechai Kaplan[2] – also accepted for use at Hod veHadar – “Who has drawn us to God’s work and given us Torah” highlights the work/service to which we are called.
My perspective also leaves room for God to make covenants with other peoples. Parents can love more than one child and know how to assign each one a suitable role. So, too, one God can relate to many peoples.
Just as Moses ascends a fiery mountain to
receive the Torah, the prophet Isaiah (chapter 8, this week’s Haftarah) beholds
Divinity (and also seraphim) through smoke. He hears the chant, “Holy, holy,
holy,” and then “the voice of my Sovereign saying, ‘Whom shall I send? Who will
go for us?’” The prophet replies, “Here am I; send me.”
After the Kedusha (vision of holiness) comes mission.
May we hear the commanding voice in the fog and know how to say, “Here am I; send me.”
[2] Apparently based on the Passover Haggadah, “From the beginning, our ancestors were idol worshipers. And now, the Place [of all] has brought us close to His worship” or the holiday musaf service.
Sunday, November 19, 2023
Parashat VaYeitzei: Rebuilding with Ḥesed
In a moment of incredible frustration Rachel demands of Jacob: “Give me sons or I die!” His response is one of great anger.
Of the
many commentators who attempt to explain his fury, the explanation of Rabbi
Isaac Arama (Spain, 1420-1494) is notable. Commenting on the creation, Arama
explains the substantive difference between “Isha-woman“ and “Chava-Eve.”
The former is indicative of those things of the woman shares with the man:
knowledge, understanding and good deeds, like those of the Matriarchs, while
“Eve” refers to the ability to bear children. Arama explains that a woman who
does not have children is prevented from the fulfilling her secondary
(literally, “small”) purpose but like a man who does not have children, her
legacy is her good deeds. Therefore, Jacob was angry at Rachel because he
wanted to teach her that the true purpose of any person, man or woman, is doing
good deeds.
Even
if Arama understood Jacob’s intentions correctly, fury was not a suitable
response. Truth spoken in anger will neither console nor educate. Be that as it
may, their exchange is hardly surprising because neither of them came from
families that knew how to clarify issues through direct conversation. Jacob is
in Haran because his parents did not know how to discuss transmission of their
inheritance, and Laban made sure that his daughters began married life with a
major failure of communications.
“When
morning came, it was Leah!” Like many readers, the rabbis were puzzled about
how Jacob could not have known, but avoid what I think is the simplest
explanation: he was drunk. It’s easy to imagine trickster Laban and his cronies
encouraging the groom to drink one toast after another so he truly would not
know with whom he was sleeping. It works, ask Lot. Apparently, the rabbis did
not want to disgrace a Patriarch by pulling him down to the level of Lot, but
we should also pay attention to the fact that of all possible solutions, they
chose one that depicts Rachel as someone who does deeds ofחסד - ḥesed, loving
kindness:
[As the Israelites were being
exiled by Nebuchadnezzar, after the destruction of the First Temple] Rachel
spoke before the Holy Blessed One: “Ruler of the World, remember that Jacob
loved me greatly, and worked for me for seven years. But when that time was up
my father chose to give him Leah in my place. This distressed me greatly, so I
told Jacob and gave him a sign, so he could distinguish between us. But then I
had pity on my sister and I taught her the sign.” (Lamentations Rabbah,
Opening 24).
Paying a
high personal price, Rachel chooses to protect the honor of her sister Leah and
responds with ḥesed (“loving kindness”), thereby sowing seeds of ḥesed
that will grow not only for her own future but also for her descendants. The
midrash continues:
The mercy of God was stirred by Rachel’s argument, and God said: “For your sake, Rachel, I will restore the house of Israel to its place, as it is written, ‘Restrain your voice from weeping, Your eyes from shedding tears; For there is a reward for your labor, declares the Lord, they shall return to their borders’ (Jeremiah 31).”
There is hope for Rachel and her descendants because of the great with ḥesed she did for her sister Leah. I wrote these words on 6 November 2023 22 Marcheshvan 5784, 30 days after the massacre and destruction of the western Negev. After the devastation, we witnessed an incredible outpouring of ḥesed. If any hope emerges from the tragedy, it will be only (or primarily) because of that ḥesed.
Parashat Vayera: If a Pillar of Salt Could Speak
Hebrew Hello, hikers! Yes, you, I’m talking to you. Have a seat for a few minutes and listen to a message that has been waiting thousands of...
-
Scroll down for Hebrew I haven’t written for a few weeks because I’ve been insanely busy. Consumed by situations more complex than I could...
-
scroll down for Hebrew My name is Miriam. I am a prophet. There’s also a well; many wells actually, but they aren’t mine. Let me expla...
-
Scroll down for Hebrew Among the details of the sacrifices prescribed in Parashat Tzav there is point of connection point with the upcoming ...

